I’ll start out by saying that while I admit I’m not really much of a Top 40 fan I provide this next bit of dialogue without bias.
To be fair my focus here won’t be so much on mainstream music as one of it’s most popular acts. This act is the Black eyed Peas.
Recently B.E.P was allowed to get up and give a performance at mainstream music’s biggest show, The Grammys, despite having not one but TWO lawsuits of plagiarism currently against them. REALLY!?!
How is it that the powers that be in this industry actually put aside such brazen claims? They might as well say that it’s ok to rip off someone else’s hard work and pass it off as your own. Don’t get me wrong here… I realize that sampling is a HUGE part of today’s music industry but at least credit is given where it’s due and rights are, for the most part, properly secured. In fact a lot of what I listen to is sample heavy and I bloody well love it.
For those of you not in the know here’s the info on who exactly is suing them and for what.
First was DJ/Producer Adam Freeland of Marine Parade. His song ‘Mancry’ off his latest album COPE was blatantly stolen without permission and used on B.E.P.’s track ‘Party All the Time’. When you listen to the two tracks side by side you can’t even say that it’s similar it’s the SAME.
The second situation, which is a bit more recent, is coming from an artist named Phoenix Phenom who claims that her track ‘Boom Dynamite’ was used as the inspiration for ‘Boom Boom Pow’. This case isn’t as clear cut but there is no denying that the two songs sound similar both rhythmically and lyrically. Not only is Phoenix Phenom suing B.E.P. over this but they are also suing the Pea’s label Interscope as well. Interscope had shown interest in Phoenix and turned them away after hearing ‘Boom Dynamite’. Is it just another COINCIDENCE that this plagiarism suit has arisen?
All in all there’s a couple things I just don’t understand. One… how can an act as popular as B.E.P. actually think it can get away with this theft and it not get caught? Their music is blasted on every god forsaken Top 40 station on the planet! Two… how can the industry allow it to happen without repercussion? I just can’t get over the fact that it seems so wrong to allow them to perform at the industry’s biggest showcase when these claims are levied against them.
Maybe in the long run I’m bitching just for the sake of bitching. I readily admit I’m not a big fan of Top 40 and B.E.P. especially. What do you think? Is it no big deal that B.E.P. still gets grand promotion on an awards show despite their legal troubles?
In the end, if this is passed off as no big deal I think it’s an arrow into the heart of an industry that barely beats as it is. Forget music that is inspired and written with emotion. You might as well use somebody else’s inspiration instead.
What People Think About The Crap I Say